Showing posts with label metal vapor arcing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label metal vapor arcing. Show all posts

RoHS and Regulating Smartly

>> Tuesday, July 6, 2010


I am all for doing the smart thing when it comes to our environment. I understand (quite well) that asbestosis and many other environmental lung disorders will be a thing of the past largely because of regulation. I know that the EPA has had a significant impact on the environment, and most of it was good. I know that California's tight air quality regulations have drastically reduced the air pollution in cities that used to be lost under smog. I've heard of creeks/rivers so polluted they could catch on fire and I'm grateful that, except off the Gulf Coast (thanks to the oil spill), that's also a rarity in this country.

And I know regulations involving lead in paint, gasoline and children's toys are a huge factor in why the lead level in this generation's children is much lower than it was in the generations that came before. But that doesn't mean that every ban is the right thing to do, even for something as dangerous as lead.

The Restriction of Hazardous Substances Directive, is a directive of the European Union intended to reduce dangerous heavy metals and two flame retardant materials in industrial wastes. Great idea, largely. There can be as much as 2 kg of lead in a cathode ray tube (which are going the way of the dinosaur) and more lead in many other components. To date, I've heard little to no complaining about those aspects of the regulation. In fact, in my technical part of the world, all I hear complaining about is lead-free solder and pure tin (i.e. lead-free) plating.

Now, before I go further on this, let me mention two things. First, I'd take this (RoHS) a lot more seriously if batteries (both those with cadmium and those with lead acid) were part of this directive - they're not. There is a battery directive that limits cadmium, but not lead, although it promotes more battery recycling. But, at this point, 90% of the lead put in products today is used in batteries. I have to say, dealing with the rest of the lead while leaving the lead battery issue largely untouched is much like closing the gate once the horse has left.

Secondly, though I have concerns about the lead-free solder, there are some uses where lead-free solder might be the right choice, for various reasons. But not always.

Now there's a whole list of issues with lead-free solder. but what I want to focus on here are those that result from the use of pure-tin plating: tin whiskers. Because reducing a tiny fraction of the lead in the environment (there must be natural sources of lead in the environment, too, right? That's where we get it... Sorry, distracted) is only the right thing to do if the cost for doing so (i.e the good of the consumer) isn't higher.

In this case, I don't think it is. Sure, in most cases of consumer electronics, the power source is small (like a battery, not covered by the RoHS) enough that metal vapor arcing is unlikely. Which means that, worst case, you get a short that shorts it out - and it's broken - and, best case, it's just an intermittent irritation. But some plugged in electronics have the power, and to spare, to create metal vapor arcing, which can not only destroy the electronics, but everything around it, readily causing a fire. High price for a few grams of lead. And, given the ubiquitous nature of electronics, a design that allows the arc once can allow it over and over again. A number of metal vapor arc failures happened in designs that included circuit protection I might add.

After all, RoHS just applies to consumer products. Which is great. Unless, say, your consumer product happens to be a car, which has a fairly high power electric system with more than enough power to induce metal vapor arcing. But, even if it doesn't burst on fire while you're driving, imagine what an intermittent power or data short can do to an electronically controlled car like most of us drive.

But, let's assume that consumer electronics are "perfectly safe" with minimal impact. Unfortunately, with the vast bulk of consumer electronics requiring lead-free electronics, parts with plating containing sufficient lead to preclude whiskering will become either impossible to find or prohibitively expensive for those applications where high reliability parts are essential.

Like medical equipment like apnea monitors and pacemakers, which are specifically exempt from the RoHS requirements (at this time), but that have had to be recalled because of tin whisker failures.

Or commercial satellite failures, which, while no one was hurt, were very very expensive. Or military equipment like planes and missiles. Or the Space Shuttle. The military, NASA and the FDA have specific prohibitions against pure tin plating, yet they've all been struck with tin whiskers from parts that got through the system.

Or there was this, the tripping of a nuclear reactor by the lowly tin whisker (and there are multiple other examples of nuclear scrams and pre-trips of nuclear reactors from the same cause). And there are more failures no one's willing to admit to except as an anecdote.

(For those who have become fascinated, check out the interesting stuff on silver whiskers and zinc whiskers, the latter having taken out whole highly redundant computer centers).

The lesson I want to impart here is that we need to be careful and cautious about what we do to the environment and ourselves, but we need to understand the implications of trying to make everything "perfect." Regulations (if they're smart) can do tremendous good, preventing such catastrophes as we see off in the Gulf right now (an abject lesson in lax regulation). But a regulation that does not take sufficient account of the consequences, can be just as destructive and short sighted.

We need to be smart about regulation instead of one extreme or the other.

Read more...

RS Classic: What Do You Know About Tin Whiskers?

>> Friday, July 2, 2010


I have a specific reason for redoing this one right now. I'll repost this because it's (I think) a good intro into the subject and carry forward over the next days as I see fit.

On today’s menu is another real something that has tremendous potential in the plot of a book (particularly science fiction, though any contemporary book could use it): tin whiskers.

Never heard of them, you say? Well, get some popcorn and sit back. Tin whiskers are cool, they’re scary, and we might be hearing much more about these before you know it. See, two years ago, I had never heard of them either. Last year [2007], I wrote a paper on them (You can also find the presentation). The subject is fascinating.

See, certain metals and alloys, particularly when used as a plating, will start to grow slim little hairs of metal. One of them is tin. Most never get more than a few mm long, but others have grown cm long under the right circumstances. Here’s a great picture of some we found in avionics boxes used to control reaction jets and aerosurfaces on the Orbiter (see page 5 of the presentation linked). If they bridge a gap with some power, but not too much, they just fuse and evaporate. If it’s a data connection, they can change a control, turn something on that shouldn’t be, for instance. But, if it has power and the conditions are right, you can get something call metal vapor arcing that will make a big unholy mess. I have some pictures in my linked presentation and paper, but there are other examples at the source for all things metal whiskery: Goddard’s Tin Whisker Website (where you can find the paper and presentation I wrote here and here). For the science minded, this is a treasure trove of data, stories, pictures, videos, pointers, etc. of all kinds of metal whiskers, well worth wandering through. All photos here link to the Goddard website.

Tin whiskers are not a new phenomena. We discovered them the hard way in the 50’s. However, it was discovered early that adding as little as 3% lead to the mix mitigated the whisker problem. But, tin plating is quick, simple, cheap, environmentally friendly and there’s no lead waste to worry over, so tin plated components began working their way into critical circuits. Tin whiskers have been blamed for losing several satellites and the redundant string for others, tripping a nuclear reactor, issues and a major recall on pacemakers, and several ugly accidents with metal vapor arcing. Really, check out those anecdotes.

Tin isn’t the only metal. Zinc and cadmium are also prone to whiskering. Zinc whiskering is becoming a serious concern in computer server facilities. Zinc whisker grows from the galvanized metal shielding on the underside of floor tiles in these facilities. When they go to upgrade or do work below, the floor tiles are lifted up and often shoved over the other floor tiles, shearing the unseen whiskers off and letting them drop into the crawlspace below. When they restart the system, the ventilation, which often flows underneath the floor, picks these whiskers up and sends them right into the computers. Huge, highly redundant server systems have been disabled this way. Really, read about it here or you can just stumble over many resources at the Goddard Tin Whisker Website. They’ve even found lead whiskers, gold whiskers and silver whiskers (though the latter is a different mechanism that grows silver whiskers like mad in a suphur rich environment. See this).

No one’s entirely sure what causes metal whiskers or what factors slow or speed the process. Whiskers may not grow for years and then grow very fast. Others might grow quickly from the beginning.

OK, so this is all cool in a geeky kind of way. So, how is this useful for fiction? Well, whiskers are an effective way to screw up all kinds of redundancy, which is frequently used to mitigate risk for space craft, with one mechanism. It’s one reason why NASA has severe restrictions on the use of pure tin plating. But, it’s not necessarily on the minds of regular people either, so this may not even be on the radar for commercial electronics. That makes it a potential factor in electric cars or planes or, in fact, anything that has critical functions that is governed by electronics. And remember, though we may come up with some way of beating them this time, a generation from now, we might forget about them all over again and have to learn it all over.

Read more...

Labels

Blog Makeover by LadyJava Creations