Showing posts with label Ebola. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ebola. Show all posts

Why the Panic over Ebola is More Dangerous than the Virus

>> Sunday, October 19, 2014

The crazy stupid politicians are screaming crisis and blaming as fast as they can, casting suspicion every immigrant, every traveler, citizen who has ever had a connection to Africa in any way as a deliberate carrier of Ebola (with their own lives willingly forfeit as well). Their own government agencies, intended to address concerns like Ebola are incompetent (even if they were among the many who voted to cut funding for both CDC and NIH) or lying and instilling a false sense of security. Naturally, it's all the President's fault, or ISIS (who the President enabled), or the Latin American refugee children (who, ironically would have dropped by the side of the road long before reaching the goal if infected), or all part of Obama's elaborate plan to attack white America via an African disease. Some of the people lambasting our epidemiologists have already shown their science chops (or rather their distinct lack of any) on the climate question, but, true to form, have not let their profound ignorance stop them from telling the experts what's what. Some should definitely know better than to cry dishonesty to our most knowledgeable experts and those worldwide who have been battling the different waves of Ebola for several decades and tens of thousands of cases.

The media outlets are right on board, trumpeting Ebolagedden and implying government corruption, incompetence, coverups, and conspiracy, often in the same sentence (despite the fact that some of these are contradictory).They're quick to parse simple language memos into dire ominous warnings, oftimes implying the bulletins say the exact opposite of what they actually say (due to creative interpretation and word parsing - see my previous post) while, at the same time, accusing these same organizations of covering up the real truth they say they just got from the bulletins. If you think a second or so of rational thought would highlight the flaws in such logic, you'd be right; unfortunately, their audience isn't getting past "Ebola, run for your lives!" and "I knew they were hiding it!"

(One individual complained to me that, though "they admitted transmission via sneezing were possible they were downplaying the likelihood." I asked them, how do you downplay a likelihood that, after nearly four decades and thousands of cases, has never happened? Sheesh!)

This sort of thing isn't a new phenomenon, but the panic, far more than the disease, is  particularly dangerous and particularly at this time.

Why?

It's dangerous for hospitals and emergency patients who need those hospitals. By implying Ebola is an unpredictable boil about to erupt on America, people are going to be cautious about contact. Which is fine to a point.

But that means vomiting or stomachaches or fevers, even mild ones, (all fairly common symptoms) could readily convince the paranoid that they've contracted Ebola so that they clog up emergency rooms (who may not be able to take such claims lightly for fear of a repeat of the Duncan incident), distracting caregivers from legitimate emergencies where lives are on the line. Caregivers (who are the mostly likely to get exposed to Ebola) may elect to take special precautions, including full gear, for anyone bleeding while feverish or vomiting. While understandable, it's largely overkill unless there's a good reason to suspect Ebola. Making Ebola a boogeyman that can attack any time or anywhere drives these types of precautions which take up time, make work more awkward and distracts caregivers from vital life-saving work. There are lives at stake, some of which might be forfeit for this unbased fear.

Regular people will also be paranoid about contact. People might panic, afraid to touch their own children that start puking or get an unexpected fever. People might become wary of contact with anyone who's been outside the country, with strangers and, I'm sad to say because Africa is always linked to Ebola, especially black strangers. Many of us are old enough to remember the stigmatizing and needless isolation of AIDS patients, hemophiliacs, homosexuals - and that stigmatizing often carried far beyond those who actually had AIDS to any gay people. If that kind of trend started with black people, it could get very ugly, very quickly.

Folks, Ebola is about transmissable as AIDS, except the window between infection and the part where someone has to be in a hospital is very short, less than three weeks at the outside. It's not easy to catch even when one is ill: the people who were living with Duncan, even during those days after the first trip to the ER until the day he started vomiting, three days later, haven't contracted Ebola (they go off quarantine today). The reason why AIDS gets transmitted so well is because it can be dormant a long time where no one (even the person who has it) may know. The reason why Ebola is currently spread so much in Africa is that, though fluid transmission is the only way, the last stage of Ebola involves spewing fluids from pretty much every orifice. And isolation facilities are few and overcrowded, with many locations having limited hygiene and sanitation facilities.

That's not the case here in the US. Which is why the WHO experts (who have been fighting this, studying and documenting it since it first appeared in 1976) say it won't be an epidemic here and that flying on a plane while not yet really sick is dangerous. And why the CDC experts, who have been following the information from WHO, have said it won't be the same here.

But the media and the politicians refuse to listen both for the very same reason. For the media, of course, it's all about profit. Getting people scared or furious keeps them glued to the TV and that's great for ratings, truth be damned, damage be damned. I mentioned that media outlets hoping to cash in on the sensationalism by spreading unnecessary fear "suck green donkey balls." That still stands, but that's not even the worst.

For politicians, there are many who have a particular interest in the distractions and stirring up the populace right now and that's the mid-term elections, barely two weeks away. If enough of the politicians, notably those who specialize in criticizing Obama and liberal policies (including, ironically, public services like CDC) either up for election this year or who want to set the stage for themselves via this election's results, can sway the uncertain elements of the crowd to vote for them to preserve their lives from Ebola, well, they'll say anything to make it so.

If they do so, and many of the obstructionists and people intent on sacrificing the American people to the 1% succeed in taking power, there will be far more harm done than even in the ERs, far more pervasive, far more long-lasting, far deeper misery than Ebola could do on its worst day. IF we let fear rule us.  That's the apex of the damage we face, the real horror this scare, rather than the virus, could do us.

I hate anyone who makes a profit from other people's misery (as Ebola surely is), but when a politician uses it for his (or her) own gain or to promote his own agenda, I think it is criminally negligible, irresponsible and, if he's a public servant, a violation of his office and oath of duty. Personally, I'd like to see such scumbags in jail. But I'll settle for voting them out in November. The irony is that the supporters for these very politicians are the ones most likely to take to paranoia - wouldn't it be interesting if their fear kept them home during the election? That, would be something like "hoist in one's own petard."

The repercussions from hysteria are already starting: Fearbola

Read more...

Ebolapallosa!

>> Thursday, October 16, 2014

OK, for those people out there losing their freaking minds over Ebola and those citing inflammatory articles that say CDC is completely contradicted by the World Health Organization (WHO) and contaminated surfaces (without description) are also possible places of transmission (and these articles cite other non-science articles, I might add, not WHO). They say:

"...wet and bigger droplets from a heavily infected individual, who has respiratory symptoms caused by other conditions or who vomits violently, could transmit the virus -- over a short distance -- to another nearby person," says a W.H.O. bulletin released this week. [1] "This could happen when virus-laden heavy droplets are directly propelled, by coughing or sneezing..."

That same bulletin also says, "The Ebola virus can also be transmitted indirectly, by contact with previously contaminated surfaces and objects."

 This is exactly what I mean when I get angry and media deliberately conflating the risk. DELIBERATELY CONFLATING THIS. Let me quote the actual bulletin referenced:

"Theoretically, wet and bigger droplets from a heavily infected individual, who has respiratory symptoms caused by other conditions or who vomits violently, could transmit the virus – over a short distance – to another nearby person." [My emphasis]

The theoretically is pretty freaking important. But more important is the entire passage this is embedded in:

Not an airborne virus

Ebola virus disease is not an airborne infection. Airborne spread among humans implies inhalation of an infectious dose of virus from a suspended cloud of small dried droplets.
This mode of transmission has not been observed during extensive studies of the Ebola virus over several decades.
Common sense and observation tell us that spread of the virus via coughing or sneezing is rare, if it happens at all. Epidemiological data emerging from the outbreak are not consistent with the pattern of spread seen with airborne viruses, like those that cause measles and chickenpox, or the airborne bacterium that causes tuberculosis.
Theoretically, wet and bigger droplets from a heavily infected individual, who has respiratory symptoms caused by other conditions or who vomits violently, could transmit the virus – over a short distance – to another nearby person.
This could happen when virus-laden heavy droplets are directly propelled, by coughing or sneezing (which does not mean airborne transmission) onto the mucus membranes or skin with cuts or abrasions of another person.
WHO is not aware of any studies that actually document this mode of transmission. On the contrary, good quality studies from previous Ebola outbreaks show that all cases were infected by direct close contact with symptomatic patients.
You'll notice that the passage, as a whole, says effectively the opposite of what the article implies.

The article also talks about contaminated surfaces: Here's the paragraph in the bulletin:
The Ebola virus can also be transmitted indirectly, by contact with previously contaminated surfaces and objects. The risk of transmission from these surfaces is low and can be reduced even further by appropriate cleaning and disinfection procedures.
Well, that sounds scary! What about the plane seat and the handle to the bathroom and the...

Calm down. In the WHO Ebola fact sheet, they kindly provide a definition of contaminated surfaces.
Ebola then spreads through human-to-human transmission via direct contact (through broken skin or mucous membranes) with the blood, secretions, organs or other bodily fluids of infected people, and with surfaces and materials (e.g. bedding, clothing) contaminated with these fluids.
  Note that "surfaces and materials" means materials contaminated with fluids (which is pretty much the same thing as contact with the fluids) which is, HEY, just what the CDC said. That doesn't mean someone sitting, not vomiting or bleeding or dribbling feces or blowing out barrels of snot has contaminated a plane full of people, especially since she was a nurse, already concerned, who I'm sure made a point not to sneeze directly on anyone. She had a low grade fever, not an eruption of body fluids. Get a damn grip.

But don't take my word for it. WHO has a memo (called, ironically enough, "WHO: Air Travel is Low Risk for Ebola Transmission") dedicated to plane travel where they say:
“Unlike infections such as influenza or tuberculosis, Ebola is not airborne,” says Dr Isabelle Nuttall, Director of WHO Global Capacity Alert and Response. “It can only be transmitted by direct contact with the body fluids of a person who is sick with the disease.”
On the small chance that someone on the plane is sick with Ebola, the likelihood of other passengers and crew having contact with their body fluids is even smaller. Usually when someone is sick with Ebola, they are so unwell that they cannot travel. WHO is therefore advising against travel bans to and from affected countries.
“Because the risk of Ebola transmission on airplanes is so low, WHO does not consider air transport hubs at high risk for further spread of Ebola,” says Dr Nuttall.
 
By the way, if you're interested in the truth, go to the source. I found these WHO pages in less than two minutes. (Also, interestingly enough, even in Africa the mortality rate is 50% which is much better than worst mortality rates [90%] but not as good as the best mortality rate [25%] of past outbreaks.

There is also the UN Mission for Emergency Response Memo which says, gasp, the same thing.
The Ebola virus only spreads through contact with bodily fluids. The World Health Organization (WHO) monitors the virus closely. Viruses do mutate but it is a complex process that takes time. Right now, as advised by WHO, the safest thing anyone can do is avoid direct contact with bodily fluids of people who have Ebola, and with surfaces and materials (e.g. bedding, clothing) contaminated with fluids.

And, of course, the much maligned CDC with their fact sheet:


When an infection does occur in humans, there are several ways the virus can be spread to others. These include:
·        •direct contact with the blood or body fluids(including but not limited to feces, saliva, urine, vomit and semen) of a person who is sick with Ebola
·        •contact with objects (like needles and syringes ) that have been contaminated with the blood or body fluids of an infected person or with infected animals

The virus in the blood and body fluids can enter another person’s body through broken skin or unprotected mucous membranes in, for example, the eyes, nose, or mouth. The viruses that cause Ebola are often spread among families and friend, because they come in close contact with blood or body fluids when caring for ill persons.

During outbreaks of Ebola, the disease can spread quickly within healthcare settings, such as clinics or hospitals. Exposure to Ebola can occur in healthcare settings where hospital staff are not wearing appropriate protective clothing including masks, gowns, gloves , and eye protection.Dedicated medical equipment (preferably disposable, when possible) should be used by healthcare personnel providing care for someone sick with Ebola.

Proper cleaning and disposal of instruments, such as needles and syringes, is also important. If instruments are not disposable, they must be sterilized before being used again. Without adequate instrument sterilization, virus transmission can continue and amplify an outbreak.

If you're keeping score, it says effectively the same thing, in fact is the most alarmist of them all. So, do us all a favor. Calm down.

And, for you media outlets hoping to cash in on the sensationalism by spreading unnecessary fear, you suck green donkey balls. By the way, all my sources are original, cited and linked.

Read more...

Labels

Blog Makeover by LadyJava Creations